CAVEAT: This list is by no means claimed to be complete. If you have any documented additions for me (professional, major junior, or collegiate only, please), send them my way! Thank you to Alan Caldwell, Jason Bau, Mark Obermayer, Jocke Persson, and statistics, Parker McDonald and eva unit zero (from HFBoards) for additions to the list
DATE
GOALTENDER
TEAM
LEAGUE
OPPONENT
NOTES
2/21/1971
Michel Plasse
Kansas City Blues
Central Hockey League
12/28/1979
Billy Smith
New York Islanders
National Hockey League
1980
Jim Tortorella
University of Maine
NCAA (Interleague)
Vasby (Sweden)
1/7/1987
Chris Clifford
Kingston Canadiens
Ontario Hockey League
12/6/1987
Darcy Wakaluk
Rochester Americans
American Hockey League
12/8/1987
Ron Hextall
Philadelphia Flyers
National Hockey League
1/21/1989
Damian Rhodes
Michigan Tech University
Western Collegiate Hockey Association
4/11/1989
Ron Hextall
Philadelphia Flyers
National Hockey League
Shorthanded, postseason
11/29/1989
Olaf Kolzig
Tri-City Americans
Western Hockey League
1/3/1991
Chris Osgood
Medicine Hat Tigers
Western Hockey League
1991
Mike Torchia
Canadian National Team
3/28/1992
Paul Cohen
Springfield Indians
American Hockey League
12/29/1992
Jeff Calvert
Tacoma Rockets
Western Hockey League
4/20/1993
Fred Brathwaite
Detroit Junior Red Wings
Ontario Hockey League
Postseason
12/26/1993
Carl Picconatto
Flint Generals
Colonial Hockey League
3/28/1994
Jason Clague
Red Deer Rebels
Western Hockey League
Postseason
1994-95
Corwin Saurdiff
Hampton Roads Admirals
East Coast Hockey League
10/9/1995
Robb Stauber
Rochester Americans
American Hockey League
11/20/1995
Phil Groeneveld
Fort Worth Fire
Central Hockey League
Wichita Thunder
3/6/1996
Chris Osgood
Detroit Red Wings
National Hockey League
1995-96
Nick Vitucci
Charlotte Checkers
East Coast Hockey League
1995-96
Olie Sundstrom
Erie Panthers
East Coast Hockey League
1995-96
Sean Gauthier
South Carolina Stingrays
East Coast Hockey League
11/9/1996
Fred Brathwaite
Manitoba Moose
American Hockey League
4/17/1997
Martin Brodeur
New Jersey Devils
National Hockey League
Postseason
1/3/1998
Andrew Allen
University of Vermont
Eastern Collegiate Athletic Conference
2/28/1998
Chad Alban
Michigan State University
Central Collegiate Hockey Association
1/2/1999
Damian Rhodes
Ottawa Senators
National Hockey League
1/5/1999
Dieter Kochan
B.C. Icemen
United Hockey League
3/16/1999
Jarmo Myllys
Luleå Elitserien
Swedish Elite League
10/22/1999
Mike Torchia
Mohawk Valley Prowlers
United Hockey League
10/30/1999
Christian Bronsard
Syracuse Crunch
American Hockey League
2/15/2000
Martin Brodeur
New Jersey Devils
National Hockey League
Game-winning goal
1/2/2001
Jose Theodore
Montreal Canadiens
National Hockey League
2/16/2001
Scott Hamilton
United States Military Academy
Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference
Sacred Heart University
3/27/2001
Mark Bernard
Toledo Storm
East Coast Hockey League
10/15/2001
Chris Mason
Milwaukee Admirals
American Hockey League
2/17/2002
Bryan McMullen
Austin Ice Bats
Central Hockey League
San Angelo Outlaws
3/10/2002
Evgeni Nabokov
San Jose Sharks
National Hockey League
10/26/2002
Mike Smith
Lexington Men O'War
East Coast Hockey League
11/16/2002
Mike Mantua
Western Michigan University
Central Collegiate Hockey Association
Ferris State University
10/5/2003
Troy Davenport
Green Bay Gamblers
United States Hockey League
St. Louis Heartland Eagles
10/10/2003
Justin Tobe
Danville Wings
United States Hockey League
Tri-City Storm
12/5/2003
Brian Eklund
Pensacola Ice Pilots
East Coast Hockey League
2/14/2004
Mika Noronen
Buffalo Sabres
National Hockey League
3/5/2004
Jordan McLaughlin
Prince George Cougars
Western Hockey League
Vancouver Giants
3/5/2004
Kevin Fines
Cape Fear Fire Antz
South East Hockey League
Winston-Salem T-Birds
3/30/2004
Justin Peters
St. Michael's Majors
Ontario Hockey League
Postseason
4/11/2004
Antero Niittymaki
Philadelphia Phantoms
American Hockey League
Game-winning overtime goal, shorthanded goal
12/29/2004
Michel Robinson
Rockford IceHogs
United Hockey League
3/3/2005
Trevor Koenig
Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies
East Coast Hockey League
4/17/2005
Seamus Kotyk
Milwaukee Admirals
American Hockey League
9/25/2005
Antoine Lafleur
Prince Edward Island Rocket
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
QMJHL debut
4/15/2006
Chris Mason
Nashville Predators
National Hockey League
1/6/2007
Jonathan Quick
University of Massachusetts - Amherst
Hockey East
3/17/2007
Mike Wall
Arizona Sundogs
Central Hockey League
Corpus Christi
10/27/2007
Jonathan Quick
Reading Royals
East Coast Hockey League
12/15/2007
David Reekie
Lincoln Stars
United States Hockey League
Chicago Steel
2/12/2008
Andreas Andersson
Rogle BK
Elitserien (Sweden)
2/20/2008
Drew MacIntyre
Manitoba Moose
American Hockey League
Game-winning overtime goal
2/22/2008
Kyle Richter
Harvard University
Eastern Collegiate Athletic Conference
Yale University
12/6/2008
Peter Delmas
Lewiston MAINEiacs
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
12/6/2008
Maxime Gougeon
Rimouski Oceanic
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
12/19/2009
Timo Pielmeier
Bakersfield Condors
East Coast Hockey League
Utah Grizzlies
ENG
3/19/2010
Chris Holt
Binghamton Senators
American Hockey League
Rochester Americans
5/1/2010
Ryan Massa
Fargo Force
United States Hockey League
Green Bay Gamblers
Postseason
2/19/2011
Brandon Jaeger
Wenatchee Wild
North American Hockey League
Dawson Creek Rage
4/25/2011
Robert Tadazak
Michigan Warriors
North American Hockey League
St. Louis Bandits
Postseason, power-play goal
12/26/2011
Cam Ward
Carolina Hurricanes
National Hockey League
4/14/2012
Jon Gillies
Indiana Ice
United States Hockey League
Des Moines Buccaneers
2/15/2013
Brian Foster
Cincinnati Cyclones
East Coast Hockey League
Trenton Titans
3/21/2013
Martin Brodeur
New Jersey Devils
National Hockey League
Carolina Hurricanes
Power-play goal
10/19/2013
Vitali Yeremeyev
Astana Barys
Kontinental Hockey League
Novosibirsk Sibir
10/19/2013
Mike Smith
Phoenix Coyotes
National Hockey League
Detroit Red Wings
11/26/2013
Mitch Gillam
Cornell University
NCAA (Interleague)
Niagara University
12/7/2013
Michael Garteig
Quinnipiac University
East Coast Athletic Conference
Union College
2/1/2014
Chris Driedger
Calgary Hitmen
Western Hockey League
Kootenay Ice
2/22/2014
Jared Rutledge
Green Bay Gamblers
United States Hockey League
Youngstown Phantoms
12/13/2014
Francois Brassard
Cape Breton Screaming Eagles
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
Quebec Remparts
SH ENG
1/16/2015
Reto Berra
Lake Erie Monsters
Americans Hockey League
Chicago Wolves
2/11/2015
Alex Larson
Nichols College
ECAC Northeast (NCAA Division III)
Wentworth Institute of Technology
2/28/2015
Francois Brassard
Gatineau Olympiques
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
Saint John Sea Dogs
ENG
10/9/2015
Tyler Parsons
London Knights
Ontario Hockey League
Sudbury Wolves
ENG
1/9/2016
Ryan Mulder
Castleton State College
New England Hockey Conference (NCAA Division III)
University of Southern Maine
ENG
3/18/2016
Stuart Skinner
Lethbridge Hurricanes
Western Hockey League
Medicine Hat Tigers
ENG
11/4/2016
Sal Magliocco
Elmira College
ECAC West (NCAA Div 3)
Stevenson University
ENG
12/2/2016
Max Milosek
UW Stevens Point
WIAC (NCAA D3)
UW River Falls
ENG
12/30/2016
Alex Nedeljkovic
Florida Everblades
ECHL
Atlanta Gladiators
ENG
1/7/2017
Etienne Montpetit
Val d'Or Foreurs
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
Quebec Remparts
ENG SHG
1/13/2017
Mathieu Bellemare
Gatineau Olympiques
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
Rimouski Oceanic
non-ENG SHG
2/24/2017
Keith Petruzzelli
Muskegon Lumberjacks
United States Hockey League
Madison Capitals
ENG
3/24/2017
Jonas Gustavsson
Bakersfield Condors
American Hockey League
San Diego Gulls
ENG SHG
4/13/2017
Dylan Wells
Peterborough Petes
Ontario Hockey League
Kingston Frontenacs
ENG (postseason)
11/18/2017
Mikhail Berdin
Sioux Falls Stampede
United States Hockey League
Muskegon Lumberjacks
ENG
12/9/2017
C.J. Motte
Quad City Mallards
ECHL
Fort Wayne Komets
ENG
1/12/2018
Evan Weninger
University of Nebraska - Omaha
National Collegiate Hockey Conference (NCAA)
University of Miami (Ohio)
ENG
1/17/2018
Tristan Berube
Gatineau Olympiques
Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
Sherbrooke Phoenix
ENG
3/10/2018
Alex Nedeljkovic
Charlotte Checkers
American Hockey League
Hartford Wolf Pack
ENG
To The Goaltender Home Page FAQ